Writing when I was sixteen felt so much easier.
In high school, I might have been a small-town Carrie Bradshaw. A little imperious and not so educated, I reveled in the self-proclaimed title of “writer.” Naturally, there was a smidge of apprehension as I set myself apart, but then I could always think about how building an empire would one day be my greatest accolade. I could peruse the archives to use for my personal statement or walk into a job interview noting my quite-cleverly-named personal blog. It’s even naively listed on my LinkedIn, as one might list summer internships or return offers.
Thus, the commodification and trendiness of my entire personality hurt like hell. One minute, you’re everybody’s biggest cheerleader: You should start a Substack, and so should you! But then you see the words proliferate and realize that when you’re sixteen, people tend to hold your ambition like a fragile egg. By twenty-one, they’ve served it fried, poached, and scrambled with cheese.
You read clever wordplay and profound allegories and wish they had been yours. Suddenly, your empire looks like nothing more than the ruins of Pompeii, and then, like everything else, what once made you proud now tints you green with envy.
When asked what it is exactly that I write, I hesitate. “Oh, you know. Journals and Substacks. Mostly personal narratives and such.” What the heck is a personal narrative? I cop out of digging deeper because I’m already a writer, and that’s enough. It was, at least.
Now, everyone is a writer writing personal narratives about their long-lost loves and inner-child vibrations. I feel like a small fish. The tiniest minnow proudly cheering on every colossal sea creature. I want to see more voices, read into the minds of people I know and strangers alike. But I still want this to be my thing. Is that too much to ask?
I have a close friend who is a real artist. She draws beautifully. I mean, stylistic portraits with vibrant illustrations, all informed by color theory. It has taken her years to achieve her prowess. She runs an Instagram account to showcase her art and accepts commissions. We often speak about our shared creativity as if our mediums are the same. But, again and again, I futilely explain to her that my art is nothing like hers. Mine is easy. No barrier to entry. I could walk up to any Tom, Dick, or Harry, ask them to write an article like this one, and they could. Everyone runs to the podium.
She affirms to me that this isn’t the case. She thinks I am a pessimist, and I think I am a realist. I’ve seen it. Every day, someone hops on the bandwagon to start a Substack, start journaling, or pick up a book. And a literate society is a strong one, but it is now a bare minimum. Congratulations, you read! We don’t give out participation awards in the real world.
Now, when I sit down to write, things feel a little hopeless. I’m not sure if I’ve had any truly unique experiences or can convey an idea that someone hasn’t already done better. I guess what must set me apart is the way I approach the craft. I’m assuming the greats—Shakespeare, Austen, Didion, and Morrison—were not the lucky few to have sui generis experiences. They just learned to take their mundane observations and transform them into a world that sits on the shelf right above our own.
Writing has become a little too relatable. Most of the articles I read live in my universe, which is to say that they hold a mirror directly to my slightly puffy, acne-ridden face. In an increasingly vain world, this works beautifully. People want to read their own experience and feel seen. But great literature once did so much more. It did not bow to individual experience. It enveloped humanity to transcend time and space. After all, we are still reading it today.
I love talking about myself, and I love writing about me too. I’m a riveting topic! Still, I’ll admit that I’m not special, and if I am only going to write about my experience, there will surely be someone out there to do it better. Writing is different from painting or music or film. It has been flattened into a skill or habit rather than a true art form.
For those of you who once called yourselves writers but now call yourselves lost, I beg you to return to the basics. View this practice from the perspective of that high-school AP Lit student, finding meaning in symbols and foreshadowing. The curtain is red for a reason. Foil characters flirt. Synecdoche and metonymy skip like stones on a still river. And while these things are not rooted in reality, they are rooted in refinement and universality. The curtain remains red no matter what’s trending or banned.
There are levels to this—words scrawled on a McDonald’s napkin at 2 a.m., pages and pages of thoughts logged in my Notes app, rage-filled journal entries, Substack slop, and then something more. Not all writers are artists, so today, being a writer is not enough. It will take a little more. You must be an explorer, a researcher, a hero, a villain, and oh so patient.
Rome wasn’t built in a day, and then it was destroyed in a moment. But we still flock to its ruins until it is built again. Patiently, we wait.
Happy Living,
“We die. That may be the meaning of life. But we do language. That may be the measure of our lives.” -Toni Morrison